'Survivor' Question of the Week #3: Which Player Left the Game Too Soon?
By Gordon Holmes
Wed, 29 Oct 2008 19:45:53 GMT
Which "Survivor" player would you have liked to have stayed in the game longer? Check out my answer and Jeff Probst's answer, then let us know who your pick is.
Click Here to Comment - Am I right? Is Jeff right? Are we both wrong? Who's your pick?
Message Edited by Gordon_Holmes on 10-29-2008 03:46 PM
Click Here to Comment - Am I right? Is Jeff right? Are we both wrong? Who's your pick?
Message Edited by Gordon_Holmes on 10-29-2008 03:46 PM
Comment
I agree about Rowanda (sp) - I believe she was from the first round, wasn't she? and a cancer survivor. Am I correct? I know she was voted off because the tribe was going by who could be the most physical help and Richard was basically running the show. In a later game, she might have made it further. I also remember that poor prison guard who was voted off first - it just would have been interesting to have had her around awhile.Thu, 30 Oct 2008 08:39:04 GMT | leona-jane
Comment
I totally forget NFL run-of-the-mill quarterback who played such a tough game he had me mesmerized at times. Plus, I believe he would have set up a charity with a goodly part of his money. He certainly would have made it work well. AND he might even be a TV sports jock now, and he is certainly better than three-quarters of the pundits and announcers out there. He and Madden would be great together. Hated to see him go - and he kept pulling them out of his hat, didn't he?Thu, 30 Oct 2008 09:29:27 GMT | leona-jane
Comment
This is the first week I am disagreeing with Jeff Probst. Sorry Jeff but I still love you. I agree with Gordon that Jonathan and Wanda should have got a chance to play the game. They were voted off just for not getting picked for a team. Remember the Pearl Islands when the castaways that were voted off got a second chance and came back. They need to do that again.I love these questions.
Thu, 30 Oct 2008 13:16:02 GMT | KathyMcDreamy
Comment
My all time favorite player who left too early was Rupert. However, Survivor brought him back for All Stars. Even more disappointing may have been this season. Fang keeps making foolish decisions. Maybe they thought Dan Kay was a really bad actor, but he could have helped his tribe out tremendously had a weaker member been voted out instead of him, whether or not he actually had the idol. Dan Kay, though, may not have been an interesting Survivor "character" in the long run. Jaquie Berg was charismatic, competitive, and caring and would have made a great "character" to the final four if the tribe would have gone with Ace, Kelly, CJ, or Sugar instead.Thu, 30 Oct 2008 16:07:04 GMT | eaglez
Comment
i agree with jeffThu, 30 Oct 2008 17:23:33 GMT | vcnewell
Comment
Jonathan and Yau Man! Both were great players and added excitement to the game for viewers.Thu, 30 Oct 2008 19:59:41 GMT | seafaress
Comment
One Word....HunterFri, 31 Oct 2008 02:15:40 GMT | Jaydub22
Comment
Your both wrong! Lets go back to Survivor: Vanuatu. The first three people voted out of the Lopevi tribe were all young active men, Brook, John P and Brady. They all deserved to go farther in the game but they were simply out numbered in the game with people who identified with the older group.Fri, 31 Oct 2008 02:20:31 GMT | sharkbball1
Comment
this show is garbage. i wouldn't waste my time watching these. adults putting themselves in these situations making believe they are really the people the pretend to be. backstabbing, lying, disrespect and animosity for your fellow man is a great tool for teaching children who watch it. they'll all wind up being ceo's, or politicians who rob people for their money just so they can be king of the hill, A number one. look at me, aren't i great, don't you just love me. NO. reality tv is a crashing BORE!Fri, 31 Oct 2008 06:21:15 GMT | calleighgirl
Comment
I think yao man . He was one of the best players out there. I would like to see him back again and also rupert. just cause he made the show worth watching.Fri, 31 Oct 2008 11:22:16 GMT | buufs
Comment
ghostgirl here, I think yoour attude sucks. we don't need you to be watching our tv show anyway. people with attudes like your s are the ones killing our kids . they learn to have your attude then not only do they hate themselves but also everyone else. the only reason we watch real tv is because we need to step away from the real world for a while . because it is full of hate . I bet you watch the news and all that. right how much more real tvcan you get then that. so don't knock us down and the world we create look at your real tv/Fri, 31 Oct 2008 11:31:48 GMT | buufs
Comment
Dan left too soon. He was the best looking of all.Fri, 31 Oct 2008 16:01:10 GMT | SheilaMcC
Comment
i would have to say pasquel..im not sure if i spelt it right..he was never voted off but had to pick a rock...cmon nowThu, 06 Nov 2008 07:48:04 GMT | dakkon300
Comment
I love Ozzy! He clearly was the ultimate survivor and should have won! Parvarti stabbed him in the back-which got her the million.Thu, 06 Nov 2008 13:48:30 GMT | Maaacb
Comment
I think James the grave digger went home too soon, both times! I would like to see him again, with Rupert and win this time. And Gervis from season one tooThu, 06 Nov 2008 14:58:14 GMT | jjrennick
Comment
I agree with Jeff about Gina (and Hunter). But the root of the evil in that tribe was Boston Rob and what do they do? They bring that **bleep** back to give him another try. Should have brought back Gina for All-Stars (instead of Amber and Hunter instead of Rob) if you really felt that way, Probst.Thu, 06 Nov 2008 20:41:59 GMT | toast_with_JAM
Comment
Osten Taylor...He was the very first quitter. As sexy as he was, he had to be the biggest punk ever to get picked for Survivor. And he had the nerve to claim NY as his home....Tue, 11 Nov 2008 21:36:23 GMT | ShellyWorld