'American Idol' Musts & Busts
'Idol' Must: Carrie Underwood
Carrie Underwood combines her beauty and talent unlike any other 'Idol' alum.
(AP Photo/Peter Kramer)
'Idol' Must: Carrie Underwood | 'American Idol' Musts & Busts | Comcast.net Music
Skip to Main Content | Skip to Categories | Skip to Search
Search
More from this Slideshow
-
'Idol' Bust: Jus... Have you seen this man? Justin Guarini exemplifies the term 'also-ran.'
(AP Photo/Lucy Nicholson)
-
'Idol' Must: Kel... Her public feud with Clive Davis notwithstanding, Kelly Clarkson remains the 'American Idol' gold standard.
It's also worth noting that when Justin Guarini stood next to Kelly, it's the closest he ever came to success.
(AP Photo/Lucy Nicholson)
-
"Idol' Bust: Rub... It's hard to believe a man of Ruben's stature would be overshadowed by the waifish 'Idol' runner-up Clay Aiken, but he was.
(AP Photo/Jim Cooper)
-
'Idol' Must: Cla... He's admitted that he's no Justin Timberlake, but Clay has carved out quite a career with hit albums and Broadway success.
(AP Photo/Richard Drew)
-
'Idol' Bust: Fan... Fantasia Barrino lands in the bust column despite receiving seven total Grammy nominations total.
(AP Photo/Jason DeCrow)
-
'Idol' Bust: Dia... Despite having had some recent success on Broadway, if you asked someone on the street who Diana DeGarmo is, they'd probably say she works in accounts payable.
(AP Photo/Kevork Djansezian)
-
'Idol' Must: Jen... Jennifer Hudson proved 'Idol' audiences wrong by earning an Academy Award for her performance in 'Dreamgirls.'
(AP Photo/Evan Agostini)
-
'Idol' Must: Car... Carrie Underwood combines her beauty and talent unlike any other 'Idol' alum.
(AP Photo/Peter Kramer)
-
'Idol' Bust: Bo ... Bo may know rock, but when it comes to success, Bo don't know Diddley.
(AP Photo/Richard Drew)
-
'Idol' Bust: Tay... After winning 'American Idol' in 2006, Hicks' eponymous debut went platinum.
Shortly thereafter, his fans, the Soul Patrol, went A.W.O.L. and Hicks was dropped by his label, J Records.
(AP Photo/Achmad Ibrahim, file)
-
'Idol' Bust: Kat... McPhee was named one of People Magazine's Most Beautiful People in 2007.
Her self-titled debut album never went gold. She was subsequently dropped by RCA Records in January 2008.
(AP Photo/Dima Gavrysh)
-
'Idol' Must: Ell... Elliott Yamin's hit single, 'Wait for You,' reached Billboard's Top 20 in 2007.
(AP Photo/Jeff Christensen)
-
'Idol' Must: Chr... He may not have won the 'Idol' title, but Chris Daughtry is still a champ.
His self-titled debut album reached number one on the Billboard charts in 2006.
(AP Photo/Jim Cooper)
-
'Idol' Must: Kel... The beautiful, bubbly Kellie Pickler won three awards at the 2008 CMT Music Awards.
(AP Photo/Matt Sayles)
-
'Idol' Bust: Buc... Bucky's had mixed success as a country artist, but sales of his 2007 debut stalled at under 400,000.
(AP Photo/Peter Kramer)
-
'Idol' Must: Jor... Last season's 'Idol' champ Jordin Sparks has scored hits with her singles 'Tattoo' and 'No Air,' featuring Chris Brown.
(AP Photo/Matt Sayles, file)
-
'Idol' Bust: Bla... Beatbox star Blake Lewis is the third-lowest-selling runner-up in American Idol history, ahead of Justin Guarini and Diana DeGarmo.
(AP Photo/Evan Agostini)