NewsWrap
Trial for Terrorists - Justice and Therapy
Surely there are legitimate differences of opinion about using civilian courts or military tribunals to try the terrorists who planned 9/11, but it is hard to separate them out from the powerful underlying emotional issues. In the reactions to the Attorney General announcement of his plan to try them in Federal Court in New York, it is easy to detect those who fear being re-traumatized and those who hope the trials will enable them to put their fears behind them."It's absolutely disgusting," said a woman whose son died in the attack. She said of Mr. Mohammed, "He's going to be, what, two blocks from ground zero, where he can see his handiwork and mock those he murdered." She started crying. "Every day I get up and know I'll never see my son again, this is just a smack in his face."
Another woman who lost her husband in Tower 2, was among scores of relatives who had signed a letter opposing regular criminal trials for them. "Its totally unfair," she said. "Why do we have to constantly relive this? When do we get to be at peace? They should be hung."
On the other hand, many hope the trials will offer closure: "Let them come to New York," said a retired deputy chief of the New York Fire Department, whose son died in the attack. "Let them get on trial. Lets do it the right way, for all the world to see what they're like."
There is no neutral place in this story. As someone who works downtown said: "its going to be very rough on some people. I'm getting goose bumps just thinking about it."
For those whose losses are less great, how much can the legal issues be separated from the political meaning of the event? There are those who see the trials as a means to repair the embarrassment and humiliation of Guantanamo, and restore our image as a nation of laws. The New York Times editorialized that the decision was, a bold and principled step toward repairing the damage wrought by former President George W. Bush with his decision to discard the nations well-established systems of civilian and military justice.
Then, of course, there are those who emphasize that we locked in a mortal struggle with a virulent enemy. Commentators in The Wall Street Journal derided the plan as show trials, and John Yoo, the Justice Department official who helped design and justify Bushs policies on torturing detainees, refers to them as an intelligence bonanza for al Qaeda. In their view, we cannot afford to offer terrorists the advantages of fairness and due process.
As Justice, blindfolded, tries to pick her way across the rubble of our emotional landscape, can she even find a place to stand?
Your Feedback |
Ken Eisold, Ph.D., is a practicing psychoanalyst and organizational consultant. He has served as president of the International Society for the Psychoanalytic Study of Organizations and as a director of the Organizational Program at the William Alanson White Institute, which he helped to found. For several years he directed the A. K. Rice Institute's National Conference on Leadership and Authority. He lives and works in New York City. For more information visit KenEisold.com
Message Edited by Kenneth_Eisold on 11-20-2009 01:17 PM…
Fri, 20 Nov 2009 18:16:14 GMT | Kenneth_Eisold
The Anti-Vaccinators
What is the meaning of the upsurge in resistance to vaccination this year? Why is the public fighting more vigorously than ever those who are trying to help them avoid serious infections?
Tue, 20 Oct 2009 15:55:49 GMT | Kenneth_Eisold
What Do Celebrity Pundits Actually Do?
Glen Beck, Rush Limbaugh, Sean Hannity – they sure make a lot of noise and get a lot of attention. But what is their impact? How do they affect the political process?
Mon, 05 Oct 2009 20:54:50 GMT | Kenneth_Eisold
Ex-Nazi Chief Gets Life
German Lt. Josef Scheungraber was convicted today of murder and and sentenced to life in prison based on evidence that put him at the scene as the ranking officer in a Nazi massacre 65 years ago. . . . . it's a glance at a hot topic of the day you may be talking about tomorrow.
Tue, 11 Aug 2009 19:59:14 GMT | Laurence_Master
Healthcare Reform Outrage
Critics of health reform say anger at town halls is genuine, while the leader of the Democrats, Nancy Pelosi say activists are following GOP game plan. . . . it's a glance at one of the top stories you may be talking about tomorrow.
Mon, 10 Aug 2009 18:03:35 GMT | Laurence_Master
Week In Review: August 1, 2009
Welcome to the Week in Review, our weekend wrap-up where we take an in-depth look back at the leading top stories and events of the past week. Explore the best of video, the week in pictures, in-depth profiles, trivia and more, it's the best of what you may have missed during your busy week.
Fri, 31 Jul 2009 20:02:15 GMT | Laurence_Master
